View IWF's current position summary on canned hunting.
View FACT SHEET by The Wildlife Society - Captive Cervid Breeding: "Issues related to these practices include spread of wildlife diseases; genetic mixing; privatization, commercialization and domestication of public wildlife resources; misperceptions of fair chase and hunting; and a potential future decline of ecological stewardship."
Video on the dangers of canned hunting produced by NWF: http://vimeo.com/5680646
The term “canned hunting” comes from the hunting practices that are common on shooting preserves. “Hunters” pay a large fee to enter a fenced-in enclosure and shoot a trophy buck. The trophy bucks that end up on shooting preserves start out on small farms, where farmers selectively breed their deer to produce bucks with large, impressive antlers. These bucks are not wild; they are raised in captivity. The bucks are fed, medicated, and habituated to humans before they are sold to shooting preserves.
As State Senator David Long says, canned hunting is "...not real hunting. It fences in these animals. Almost every real hunter that I talk to says it's a terrible idea and they don't support it."
How do shooting preserves violate ethical standards?
Hunting captive deer that cannot escape from enclosed pens violates the principle of fair chase. Shooting captive deer in a pen is not ethical. Hunting preserves undermine Indiana’s long held wildlife management philosophy that all wildlife are held in public trust and managed by the state for all citizens. It also violates the North American Model of Wildlife Conservation.
How do shooting preserves threaten wildlife health?
The health of Indiana’s wild deer herd is threatened when captive deer on shooting preserves are held in high density populations that promote the spread of disease.
Of greatest concern is Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD), a contagious neurological disease that quickly spreads among captive herds and is transmitted by animal to animal contact or animal to soil contact. Soil contaminated with CWD carries the disease vector, called prions, for years, and deer must be excluded from the area to avoid spreading the disease.There is no cure for CWD. Death is always the result.
The interstate transportation of deer to hunting preserves also contributes to health concerns. Shooting preserves often import deer from out of state to meet the demand for trophy bucks. If the deer carries CWD, the disease can jump to the receiving state. We’ve already had a close call. Late last year it was discovered that a deer farm in Pennsylvania had CWD in its herd, and that some of the exposed deer had been transported to a deer farm in Indiana. By the time the Board of Animal Health contacted the Indiana shooting preserve to test their herd for CWD, some of the exposed deer had already escaped through an open fence. One exposed trophy buck is still unaccounted for, and is evidence that CWD can easily jump from captive herds to wild deer populations.
Another health threat is bovine tuberculosis. Indiana has had outbreaks of bovine TB in deer and cattle in recent years. Further bovine TB outbreaks could jeopardize the Indiana beef producer industry.
How do shooting preserves threaten Indiana's economy?
Deer hunting in Indiana contributes over $300 million annually and supports >1600 jobs. Anything threatening Indiana’s wild deer population would have a negative economic impact.
CWD management in Indiana would cost the state huge amounts of money. Disease surveillance programs must be dramatically increased and new disease management steps must be taken at the state’s expense. Taxpayers are liable for captive deer herds condemned due to disease. Hunters and anglers license fees are spent to fund State monitoring of CWD. The 2012 federal budget for both CWD surveillance activities and the study of prion disease were cut, pushing the financial burden to the states. Twenty-three (23) states now have CWD in wild and/or captive deer populations and have spent literally millions of dollars of their state’s natural resources budget to combat CWD. Six states have been added in the last two years and all were associated with captive deer facilities and moving captive deer. Wisconsin has now spent more than 50 million dollars. The North Carolina Wildlife Resource Commission predicts CWD would cost the state $35 to $54 million in recreational economic activity each year.
What do sportsmen and women think of "canned hunting"?
Most sportsmen and women are against canned hunting. A 2007 IDNR Division of Fish and Wildlife survey reported Indiana deer hunters responded 3.75 to 1 they were “extremely concerned” or “very concerned” about canned hunting verses those who responded “not concerned”.
April 14th, 2015 - Article from the Indy Star:
January 16th, 2014 Article from the Indy Star: http://www.indystar.com/story/news/2014/01/16/indiana-high-fence-hunting-bill-may-advance/4518517/
October 15, 2013 Attorney General Gregory Zoeller filed a Notice of Appeal of the Harrison County Court ruling in the case of the Indiana Department of Natural Resources vs. Whitetail Bluff, LCC.
The IWF press release from October 11, 2013 supporting an appeal may be found here.
To read the Harrison County Court Decision from September 27, 2013 that is being appealed click here.
To read the earlier Owen County Court Decision from November 29, 2012 click here.
In 2015, HB 1453 looked to provide licensing and inspection requirements for shooting preserve operations and to establish related fees. The original bill passed the House but was defeated in the Senate.
In 2013, HB 1194 looked to legalize shooting preserves and "canned hunting" in Indiana.
This bill was never heard in committee; however a provision was added to SB 487 that would have legalized the existing Indiana shooting preserves. This bill died in conference committee.
In 2012, HB 1265 looked to legalize shooting preserves and "canned hunting" in Indiana. This bill stalled in the Senate.
IWF urges you to take the time to write and call your legislators, write your letters to the Editor, etc. All of your efforts are of great value in this fight.
Additional Q & A Resource from the Chronic Wasting Disease Alliance